The daring, clever, suspenseful and sound of R. Balki. sucks simply will not allow you to keep mother. Aman Pant’s magnificent background rating recreates the songs of Guru Dutt’s classics. pyaasa Y Kaagaz Ke Phool in hypnotic addictive loops. She immediately needed to listen to the songs of the good Sachin Dev Burman and the whiplash phrases of the immortal Sahir Ludhianvi once more.
And that is what struck me in regards to the music of pyaasa Y Kagaz Ke Phool this time: whereas each track on Pyaasa is nice, your complete fame for immortality on Kagaz Ke Phool rests on simply two songs: the legitimately revered Waqt ne kiya kya haseen situm sung by Geeta Dutt and Mohd Rafi’s Dekhi zamanein kis yaari bichde sabhi baari baari.
Take these two songs in Kaagaz Ke Phool, and we’ve got little or no left to carry on to. The opposite songs within the movie hardly do justice to the artistic skills of the Burman-Kaifi Azmi mixture. San san woh chali hawa, Udd ja udd ja pyasa bhanwre, Hum tum jisse kehte hain, Ek do teen chaar aur panch Y Ulte seedhe dao lagaye They don’t seem to be, I concern, anyplace close to one of the best of Burman or Azmi.
No doubt, the centerpiece of the Kaagaz Ke Phool the soundtrack is by Geeta Dutt Waqt ne kiya kya haseen situmIt is among the finest Hindi film songs of all time. Listening to it once more makes me deeply unhappy like each time I take heed to it. And it would not simply must do with the deep melancholy of the phrases and compositions.
My sorrow for the melody runs deeper: Waqt ne kiya kya haseen situm he deserved the vocal validity of Lata Mangeshkar. This isn’t to say that Geeta Dutt hasn’t sung it properly. She has. However the composition and the phrases would have taken on a totally unexplored dimension in Lataji’s voice. Geeta Dutt permeates the lyrics with ache. Lataji would have taken the track past ache.
Needs, sadly, can’t be horses. She was at all times Geeta Dutt within the Guru Dutt films. In none of her masterpieces of pyaasa a Kaagaz Ke Phool a Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam Y Baharen Phir Bhi Aayengi Will you discover the life-giving voice of Lata Mangeshkar?
This was a bone of rivalry for Sachin Dev Burman, who as soon as stated, “So long as I’ve Lata, I’ve nothing to fret about.” pyaasa Y kaagaz ke phool, Burman needed to work with out Lataji. In Sahib Bibi Aur Ghulam composer Hemant Kumar additionally confronted the identical scenario, although he used Asha Bhosle’s voice for Waheeda Rehman whereas Geeta Dutt sang all these haunting recollections for Meena Kumari since Geeta did not sing for Waheeda (who was rumored to be in a relationship with the filmmaker).
Solely in Chaudhvin Ka Chand (1960) acquired Lataji to sing his solely track in Guru Dutt’s cinema. The track Badle badle grouper sarkaar nazar aate hain it was composed by Ravi Sharma, who insisted that Lataji sing the quantity, as he felt that solely she might do him justice. Geeta Dutt dropped that track because it was filmed at Waheeda Rehman for whom Geeta refused to sing. In Chaudhvin Ka Chand, Geeta solely has one solo, one marriage ceremony track Baalam se milan hoga which was lip-synched on display by an unknown actress.
The Dutts’ insistence on Geeta Dutt’s voice brought about no stress in Lataji’s relationship with Geeta Dutt. Lataji instructed me that they have been very shut mates and that Geeta Dutt confided all her issues to Lataji.
To all those that marvel to at the present time what waqt ne kiya would have sounded in Lataji’s voice, right here is a few encouraging info: Lataji has sung waqt ne kiya in 1994 as a tribute to Geeta Dutt 35 years after its unique composition.
To name Lataji’s model of Waqt ne kiya kya haseen situm beautiful, made when he was 65 years outdated could be an understatement. Waqt (time) definitely hadn’t carried out something Location (offense) in his voice. The center sings fascinated with Lataji waqt ne kiya It will have appeared like 1959 once I was 30 years outdated.
Subhash Okay Jha is a Patna-based movie critic who has been writing about Bollywood lengthy sufficient to know the trade inside out. Tweet at @SubhashK_Jha.
learn all Final Information, trending information, cricket information, bollywood information, Indian information Y present information right here. Comply with us on Fb, Twitter and Instagram.