Experts Weigh In: The Best and Worst Tequilas at Costco

Costco is more than just a budget-friendly grocery haven; for tequila enthusiasts, it can also be a treasure trove. However, availability can be hit or miss, as not all Costco locations are licensed to sell alcohol. State regulations influence whether you can grab your favorite tequila while shopping for bulk goods, so it's wise to check local laws before heading to the store.

For those lucky enough to browse the tequila aisle, the choices can be overwhelming. To simplify the process, we consulted experts in the field: Victor Tenorio, beverage director at Fat Rosie’s, Chris Mottler, a certified ITA tequila sommelier, and Lauren Castaño, a tequila sommelier and digital creator. Their insights reveal a mix of standout bottles and those best left on the shelf.

One of the top recommendations is G4 tequila, celebrated for its additive-free quality. Tenorio praises it as a personal favorite, stating, "I am a big additive-free tequila fan." Castaño echoes this, highlighting its agave-forward profile, which stays true to its roots in Jalisco's highlands. Additive-free tequilas avoid artificial flavoring, allowing the natural taste of the agave to shine.

On the other hand, Don Julio, a brand that many recognize due to its recent collaboration with Popeyes, has come under scrutiny. Although it has been a staple since 1942, Tenorio suggests that its quality has declined since Diageo acquired the brand in 2014. This sentiment resonates with consumers as discussions on forums like Reddit indicate that many believe Don Julio 1942 no longer justifies its price tag. Additionally, a recent class action lawsuit against Diageo claims the tequila isn’t made from 100% Blue Weber agave, contrary to its labeling.

Meanwhile, Tequila Ocho stands out as another expert favorite, appreciated for its rich flavor and additive-free nature. Tenorio describes it as the best option Costco has to offer, while Mottler points out its commitment to showcasing individual agave estates, making it a fascinating choice for connoisseurs.

When it comes to Costco's own Kirkland Signature tequila, the experts advise caution. Allegations of false advertising have emerged, with claims that it does not contain the 100% agave it advertises. Castaño expresses concern that if these allegations are proven, it could tarnish the tequila market's credibility. Tenorio adds that he would not recommend Kirkland Signature tequila, noting the brand’s lack of recognition in the distilling world.

Another brand worth mentioning is Don Fulano, which, despite being relatively new since its 2002 launch, is backed by fifth-generation agave farmers. Castaño highlights its quality, emphasizing that the handling of agave throughout production is critical to the final product's taste. Alongside Tequila Ocho and Patrón, Don Fulano is among her top recommendations at Costco.

Ultimately, whether you are a tequila aficionado or just looking to expand your palate, the insights from these experts can guide you toward making informed choices in the tequila aisle. With a mix of established brands and hidden gems, Costco can be a great place to discover quality tequila — if you know what to look for.

Source: www.thetakeout.com