Tel Aviv, Israel – The Israeli military revealed the primary outcomes of its inside investigations into the colossal navy and secret service failure of October 7, 2023 on Thursday and describes how the upper officers They underestimated the Hamas After which they misunderstand the early warnings that an vital assault would come.
The investigation tried to reply the query that Israel has amazed since that day, as hundreds of armed males from Hamas in Israeli communities, navy bases and a music pageant:
The place was the military?
The Israeli navy officers mentioned they devoted tens of hundreds of hours to place collectively the key companies, and their subsequent response to the assault, during which round 1,200 folks, primarily civilians, and 250 had been taken hostage, for the Jews from the Holocaust on essentially the most deadliest.
The survivors waited for lengthy hours after an assault that started within the early morning hours of a Jewish trip to be saved by the troopers.
In an informative assembly with journalists on the day earlier than the publication of a few of their first conclusions, Israeli navy officers advised that might not be recognized in keeping with the foundations of the military incorrect assumptions Concerning the abilities and intentions of Hamás in addition to what some navy officers have referred to as “Seeks“Exact intelligence, which didn’t exist.
The defective imaginative and prescient of Hamas was not largely questioned in Israeli secret service circles and a excessive command and led to various errors.
Amongst them one Chaotic navy response Within the early morning hours of the assault after the troops alongside the border had been shortly overwhelmed and the southern command of the military and the division of the Gaza Strip was overcome.
A girl runs on October 7, 2023 to her concrete dwelling in Ashkelon, Israel. Picture Tamir Kalifa for the New York OccasionsThe conclusions of navy and intelligence errors largely coincide with the detailed research of native and worldwide media.
However the navy now presents Your individual model Israeli navy officers mentioned of the occasions for causes of accountability.
The military He didn’t coordinate His investigation with different businesses, akin to the interior safety authority Shin Guess, which can be accountable for the gathering of secret companies within the Gaza Strip or within the police.
Politicians had been additionally not addressed and the federal government’s determination -making, which was carried out for years earlier than the assault.
The Prime Minister, Benjamin NetanyahuHe repeatedly mentioned that he answered tough questions after the struggle and rejected a broad public declare of an impartial fee that may decide private accountability.
The inner investigations by the military had no purpose of discovering particular person accountability, civil servants mentioned.
This might later come underneath the command of the pinnacle of the incoming navy employees. Pellet pronounswho will exchange lieutenant basic Herzi Halevi in the beginning of March.
They mentioned the principle purpose was to be taught classes of the debacle.
Halevi took on private accountability for the failure of military underneath his command to guard the Israelis and introduced that he would resign final month.
Aharon Haliva, former head of the Israeli navy secret service, returned in 2024, as did the pinnacle of the Israeli military.
Additional resignations shall be anticipated within the coming weeks and months.
In response to the officers, the military’s most vital conclusions embody:
– Hamas has had lately cheated Israel to imagine that I used to be excited by the remainder and enchancment of the financial situations in Gaza.
The military targeted primarily on Iran and the Hisbollah, each spectacular enemies of the Lebanese militant group.
Israeli troopers who patrol in Sdeerot, Israel, to Hamas’ assault in 2023 on the day. Picture Tamir Kalifa for the New York Occasions– The assault was not improvised.
The military acknowledged the studies that he had discovered an operational invasion plan for Hamas with the title within the code. “Jericho WallBy 2022, which says that it was initially designed in 2016.
Hamas took on the mandatory energy with out Israel knew it.
The doc described with about 40 pages, level by level, the kind of devastating invasion, which passed off on October 7.
In a written abstract of among the most vital conclusions, the military mentioned: “The data was typically misunderstood as a plan unrealistic or inconsistent”.
– Earlier than October 7, the navy rated that the risk levied by Hamas was restricted to A Restricted quantity From concepts in 4 to eight factors alongside the border, not within the dozens that had been seen through the assault and that an assault of this man would have an effect on dozens of militants, not hundreds.
– Israel had assumed that an vital change in Hamas could be preceded by A Early intelligenceNonetheless, there was no earlier data from a deliberate assault for October 7 or a tactical willingness to alert.
Because of this, solely common forces had been used to defend the border, as standard for a Saturday, which was additionally a Jewish vacation.
– Within the evening of October sixth to seventh, some early indicators had been acquired that one thing irregularly passed off in Gaza, such because the activation of dozens of cellphones that had been outfitted with Israeli SIM playing cards.
Nonetheless, the Israeli officers additionally discovered sufficient calming indicators to feed present prejudices on Hamas’ abilities, the military mentioned.
(The primary report approached within the months earlier than the assault on October 7, which appears to have been launched, not expressly the warnings of the low stage of the military about unusual actions.)
– The assault occurred in three waves.
The primary within the first half hour included round 1,200 Hamas instructions. The second from round 7 a.m. to 9 a.m. consisted of round 2,000 different instructions and armed males from different armed organizations.
The third consisted primarily of A The gang civilian Inspired by the navy commander of Hamas.
– Solely at 1 p.m. did the Israeli navy headquarters and the commanders create an excellent image of the Normal scale of the assault.
The preliminary response of the armed and official civilians and troopers who got here alone was not sufficient to pillow the blow of the primary few hours.
Three brigade commanders and several other battalion commanders and society had been killed. We needed to wait till the evening of October 9 till the navy defined that it had restored the operational management of the border areas.
We needed to wait till the evening of October ninth in order that the navy explains this to elucidate this That they had restored the working management from border areas.
Up to now few days, the navy started to current their conclusions to the residents of the attacked communities.
The reactions have been assorted:
Some residents mentioned that investigations in reference to their villages raised extra questions than solutions, and others mentioned they’d acquired a brand new perspective.
Amir Tibon, Israeli journalist and inhabitant of one of many villages, Nahal Oz, praised the navy’s investigation as “deep and critical”.
He mentioned that “he believed that he performed all tough factors with out washing any laundry.”
Nonetheless, he added that it was basically a tactical report that might not exchange the necessity for an impartial and full analysis fee.
Tibon, creator of a current ebook “The Doorways of Gaza”, in regards to the horrible expertise that his household lived on October 7, and the broader battle between Israelis and Palestinians, mentioned that navy analysis offered some new particulars of what he described as ” Heroic battle For the protection of Laach OZ ”, if not many.
One factor he knew was that three waves from attackers had entered their village, not two, as he had thought earlier than, and that the third arrived round 11 a.m.
“This exhibits absolutely the insanity of how lengthy the military took to arrange and ship an ideal energy to save lots of us,” he mentioned.
The assault by Hamas triggered for 15 months, whereas Israel tried to eradicate Hamas in Gaza and kill greater than 48,000 Palestinians, most of them ladies, youngsters and the aged, in keeping with the Gaza Ministry of Well being, which doesn’t distinguish between fight anti and civilians.
The struggle left a big a part of the Ruins slave and has unfold to a wider regional battle.
C.2025 The New York Occasions Firm